Catholic Leaders Quail Over Contraceptives

Category:  BloggERy
Wednesday, February 8th, 2012 at 4:02 PM
Catholic Leaders Quail Over Contraceptives by Jay Stevens
The Local News

Some time ago, I wrote about Pennsylvania Representative Joe Pitts' opposition to the Obama administration mandate that insurers cover contraceptives. Where Joe Pitts goes -- a ringleader for the secretive group of conservative religious policymakers called "The Family" -- you can find the US Congress of Catholic Bishops.

Sure enough, when the new regulations were finalized by the Department of Health and Human Services requiring that organizations affiliated with religion -- unlike religious organizations, which are exempt from the requirement -- are also required to provide insurance that covers contraceptives, Catholic leaders erupted, some even going so far as to vow resistance to the law.

Some surprising voices joined in the fray on behalf of the bishopric, including liberal columnist, EJ Dionne, who wrote that Obama "utterly botched the admittedly difficult question of how contraceptive services should be treated under the new health-care law." Even Erie's former House representative, Kathy Dahlkemper, whose one term was dedicated to health care reform, apparently would have torpedoed the whole thing if she knew about the rule

It's a weird issue to make a big deal over -- not for Obama -- but for the bishopric's apologists.

For starters, access to affordable contraception is critical to women's health. When and if to have children is one of the most fundamental acts of self-expression a woman has, one with enormous consequences to her income, career, relationships, and, of course, health. The rule affects only those organizations with employees and those insured who are not predominantly Catholic -- hospitals, universities, where students, patients, and employees may not share the religious values of their employers.

For another, U.S. Catholic parishoners disagree with the Church's stance. At least one study has shown that 98 percent of Catholic women have used contraception, and a majority of Catholics agree with the Obama administration's contraception mandate for insurers

That is, this really isn't a debate over the extent religion is free to impose its values on society in general, if those values are harmful. There's no debate that Christian Scientists, say, have the right to deny any health care treatment for their employees, or even family members. 

In short, you get the feeling here the issue for the bishopric apologists isn't contraceptives, "sin," or religious freedom, but a defense of the Catholic leadership, even as it's advocating policy that's injurious to human health and disrespectful of individual liberty. That is, it's the Catholic hierarchy that's at stake here, not souls.

Erie Reader: Vol. 5, No. 20
Now Available — Pick It Up Today


Associate Editor Alex Bieler breaks down the West Coast band's expansive new album, which comes out Oct. 16.

Lyons Den Productions shares the incredible news of their upcoming eco-horror film, Unearth.

Hip-hop meets cat sounds in the wonderfully weird Meow The Jewels.

High school football provides priceless entertainment. 

Rain barrels are reimagined into works of art for “Don’t Give Up the Drip.”



High school football provides priceless entertainment. 

Rain barrels are reimagined into works of art for “Don’t Give Up the Drip.”


The human body is capable of amazing things.

The Rocky Horror Show is the most interactive musical in theatrical history — the audience is half the fun. 

The Martian, a film adapted from a sci-fi novel, is set to release on Oct. 3. 

More than 60 artists’ works will be on display at the Woman’s Club of Erie in their 3rd Annual Fine Art Gallery Show. 

Tyler Smilo and Max Garcia Conover put on a lesson in modern folk.

 Goat, Kyozin Yueni Dekai, and Johnny James and the Indeterminates will be bringing the noise to Erie Ale Works.

The emblematic relationship between EPS and the City of Erie.

Channel your aggression the right way by punching your ticket to see veteran rockers Godsmack and Rob Zombie play Erie Insurance Arena.