PA Republicans Shelve Mandatory Ultrasound Bill...For Now

Category:  BloggERy
Monday, March 5th, 2012 at 1:11 PM
PA Republicans Shelve Mandatory Ultrasound Bill...For Now by Jay Stevens
Alibaba.com

You may be following the news that Virginia recently passed a bill that mandates ultrasounds for women seeking abortion. Virginia's bill made national headlines largely because its provisions would have required transvaginal ultrasound procedure, which to some sounded an awful lot like government-sponsored rape:

Because the great majority of abortions occur during the first 12 weeks, that means most women will be forced to have a transvaginal procedure, in which a probe is inserted into the vagina, and then moved around until an ultrasound image is produced. Since a proposed amendment to the bill—a provision that would have had the patient consent to this bodily intrusion or allowed the physician to opt not to do the vaginal ultrasound—failed on 64-34 vote, the law provides that women seeking an abortion in Virginia will be forcibly penetrated for no medical reason. I am not the first person to note that under any other set of facts, that would constitute rape under the federal definition.

(Whether or not this is hyperbole -- some argue consent is implicit in agreeing to an abortion -- probably depends on your point of view, tho' I suspect if your point of view is at the wrong end of the transducer, you'd probably agree with Lithwick.)

Since then, the Virginia has backed off a little on the bill, and only mandates an external ultrasound.

Pennsylvania Republicans introduced a bill similar to Virginia's original bill, but with some extra added bits:

Critics say provisions in the bill, which include a requirement that the view screen for an ultrasound to be placed within a woman's field of vision is intended to make women change their mind. Rapp's bill would allow women to look away from the display.

In addition, the doctor or technician who performs the ultrasound would have to verify in writing whether the woman accepted or refused opportunities to view the image of listen to the fetal heartbeat when it's present and detectable. That documentation would be placed in the woman's permanent medical record.

The bill recently made it through committee and was originally scheduled to go to the floor for a vote later this month. 

Only late last week, the vote was postponed:

Stephen Miskin, spokesman for House majority leader Mike Turzai, R-28, Pittsburgh, confirmed the delay Wednesday night, citing concerns raised by the medical community. He said there is no timeline to take up the legislation.

The Pennsylvania Medical Society opposes the bill on grounds it could interfere with the physician-patient relationship. The bill would set a dangerous precedent by legislating specific diagnostic protocols, the society said.

This is a vital point lost in the is-it or is-it-not debate on whether the procedure is "rape." Mandated medical procedures based solely on political considerations obviously cross a dangerous line. 

Of course, it's not likely the bill was really pulled for those reasons. What's more probable is that the national furor over the Virgnia bill gave Pennsylvania legislators pause. Whether it's just to "soften" the bill to something like Virginia's or not remains to be seen.

Erie Reader: Vol. 4, No. 17
Now Available — Pick It Up Today

CURRENT

Fitness trainers hate this one weird trick

Stories you may have missed from the Erie Reader archive. This week: Bencher's Union and "legal graffiti."

Three Eerie Roller Girls talk about the rise of roller derby, the art of the sport, and what goes into choosing a Roller Girl moniker

Local Film Office Announces Tax Credit Seminar for Filmmakers.

Bob Marley? Live music outdoors? Free show? This is a Sunday fun-day.

IN THIS ISSUE

The Art of Patricia Kearney: Selected Work 1975-2013

Erie Man Returns to Troubled Homeland to Document Crisis

No Second Guessing The New Depression starts with circus-like fanfare, but there's no funny business after that – only serious rhymes layered upon thick, jazzy samples that don't neglect the booming bottom-end we all appreciate.

If you are an inveterate fan of New Jersey pop-punk quartet The Gaslight Anthem, you will likely be disappointed or at least befuddled by their latest release.

After releasing their debut album back in 2011, Buffalo-quartet The Albrights return with their self-titled sophomore release, and the results are as catchy as ever.

The sole founding members of Spoon have mastered the art of piecing together separate sonic parts to create a memorable whole, carefully constructing songs with basic elements before adding special touches through audio engineering tricks to dazzle all of the headphone listeners out there.

German Heritage Festival, Zabawa Polish Festival, and the Erie County Fair -- all happening in two weeks!

Unicorns and vampires? FILM's got you covered, Erie.

Two nights, two killer shows: Chrome Moses w/ Daybreak Radio, and The Burning River Ramblers at King’s Rook Club.

Seventy years ago, three Erie brothers gave the ultimate sacrifice.