Street Corner Soapbox: Birtherism

Categories:  Street Corner Soapbox    Opinion
Wednesday, August 22nd, 2012 at 8:00 AM
Street Corner Soapbox: Birtherism by Jay Stevens
A. Conaway

Birtherism still lives. I know. I encountered it on Facebook when one of my “friends” posted a link and a video detailing how President Barack Obama’s long-form birth certificate – released early in 2011 – is actually a forgery.

The basis of the accusation is two-fold. First, the computer file type of the certificate – a PDF – contains multiple embedded layers akin to the kind photo-editing software would create. Second, there are “mistakes” – mostly supposed anachronisms —in the certificate. Together, this “evidence” points to the presidential birth certificate being fake.

In less than 10 seconds after reading this claim, I was able to find the relevant page on Snopes.com – the site that examines urban legends and hoaxes – that debunked it. Simply put, the layers in the file are natural to how a document would look after it was scanned – which it no doubt was. And the “mistakes” in the document, well, aren’t.

Ten seconds. Less than ten seconds. That’s all it took to find out the truth behind the claim that Obama’s certificate was faked. The question I was left with was, why wouldn’t you take the time to find out?

Think about it. The idea that Obama wasn’t born in Hawaii, that there’s a large and pervasive conspiracy engineering a false background for the president so that he would be elected to the White House, and so that he could remain there – it’s a pretty crazy idea to begin with, even if there were some plausible evidence to support it. But there isn’t any. Just ginned-up evidence like my Facebook friend’s claim.

So what does it say about someone who believes something like that immediately and without doubt? And without checking first? Emerson said that, “people do not seem to realize that their opinion of the world is also a confession of character.”

Welcome to contemporary politics. Where an entire swath of the political spectrum has abandoned reality – on presidential birth certificates, global warming, and socialism – but is treated seriously by the mainstream media. Politics is supposed to be about civic engagement, about public discourse. At its best, we apply reason to common problems and work them out. And we are plagued with enormous common problems. The growing divide between rich and poor. The sluggish economy, and dearth of jobs. The shrinking of the middle class. A looming energy crisis, and, yes, global warming.

These problems are real. They should be at the center of debate this summer. But they won’t. Instead we’ll be talking about birth certificates and scientific conspiracies and death panels.

I know I’m supposed to keep discourse open. I know that it’s too easy nowadays with blogs and social media so prevalent and abundant to simply find a comfortable corner of the online world and hide away in an echo chamber of like-minded opinions. I know all this .But I am still un-friending the Birther on Facebook. There is discourse we should not tolerate.

Jay Stevens can be contacted at Jay@ErieReader.com

Erie Reader: Vol. 4, No. 23
Now Available — Pick It Up Today

CURRENT

Interstellar sweeps us away in the science, leaving us to drift among the stars and observe in wonder rather than understand. For this, it is utterly demanding of second and third viewings -- a Nolan trademark.

As media satires go, it may not break any new ground, but it’s a rare piece of work that brings a living, breathing, if somewhat derivative ferocity to a familiar concept.

Are you spatchcocking your bird this Thanksgiving? No? Snort. All the really hip people are.

When a cello sounds like our collective soul

Take a break from another miserable Monday to read today's terrifying headlines from around the world: the U.S. continues nuclear talks with Iran, a fatal police shooting shocks Cleveland, and a young man from Philly is named a Rhodes Scholar. As always, we've got you covered. 

IN THIS ISSUE

The popular genre-bending cellist and composer brings his distinct brand of indie folk to Erie.

The comedy legend makes his first Erie appearance.

Local organization Pro Wrestling Rampage celebrates its 7th anniversary.

Addressing the future of athletics in the Erie School District.

The imminent closing of Shur-fine on West Eighth Street will result in a food desert.

In 2102, a van and a narrow patch of asphalt changed Bob Sonnenberg’s life permanently.

This crowdfunding program could be the answer Erie needs to foster new businesses.

To invest, or not to invest taxpayer money in the Public Safety Radio System – that is the question.

The Texas-based band brings their metalcore to Basement Transmissions.

The real reason the Republican Party came out on top Nov. 4.