Street Corner Soapbox: Contraception and the President

Category:  Street Corner Soapbox
Thursday, February 16th, 2012 at 9:14 AM
Street Corner Soapbox: Contraception and the President by Jay Stevens
aconaway

Last week, religious leaders -- especially the US Congress of Catholic Bishops -- were furious that the Obama administration wasn't extending its religious exemption on a health care rule that employee insurance must cover contraceptives to religiously-affiliated organizations like hospitals and universities. Critics called the payment for contraceptive services a violation of religious freedom, despite the fact the rule in no way interferes with the preaching or exercise of Catholic doctrine. Priests can still preach against contraceptives and parishioners can still refuse to use them.

The criticism also ignored the fact that "religious believers and institutions are not entitled to an exemption from generally applicable laws," according to UCLA law professor Adam Winkler in a TPM.com interview. Winkler cited the Supreme Court decision, Employment Division v. Smith, which found that states could deny unemployment to people fired for religious activities that are illegal -- in this case, two Oregon men fired for consuming peyote, a drug associated with Native American religious ceremony. “To permit this would be to make the professed doctrines of religious belief superior to the law of the land," wrote the conservative Catholic justice for the majority, "and in effect to permit every citizen to become a law unto himself.”

Imagine, if you will, Muslim-affiliated businesses enforcing Sharia law over its employees, or Christian Science-affiliated businesses denying all health care coverage for their employees, and you get the idea of what it means for Catholics Bishops to lobby to enforce its view on contraceptives on the employees of Catholic-affiliated institutions.

In short, the Obama administration had no compelling legal reason to change its rule. But it did. It reached an agreement with insurers. Religious-affiliated organizations have the right to refuse to pay for contraceptive coverage, which insurers will then provide for free to employees. Why? Because it's cheaper than not to provide the coverage.

Furious, Catholic leaders decried the compromise, and Republicans quickly took up the banner of "religious freedom." Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell vowed to pass a law allowing any employer to be able to deny coverage for contraceptives to its employees, and suddenly the issue became plain as day. It wasn't about employers having to pay for contraceptives, it's about employers not being able to force their employees to adhere to conservative Christian doctrine.

Pundits are now falling over themselves divining electoral meaning from the debate. Conservatives gleefully claim that Obama has now gotten himself entangled with the Catholic church and see dire consequences. Liberals rush to proclaim the whole thing a trap set by the canny: not only do a majority of Americans favor the administration's contraceptives rule, so do a majority of Catholics. And if Republican Senators Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins are any indication, it's likely a large proportion of women conservatives do, too. The issue, then, is a handy wedge to slice large portions of the independent vote to the president -- particularly women voters, the vast majority of those in their childbearing years are taking contraceptives, some 65 percent, according to a 2010 Guttmacher Institute study.

And that's what's being lost in the claims for "religious freedom," isn't it? While Catholics claim the rule puts the government between them and their God, they advocate putting their church between women and their doctors.

Erie Reader: Vol. 5, No. 13
Now Available — Pick It Up Today

CURRENT

Bob Protzman lines up some upcoming jazz festivals that may intrigue you.

2015 has been a good year for new music, but we can't keep track of everything. Here are four albums from the first half of 2015 that we didn't review and still deserve your attention.

FILM screenings award-winning documentary Wednesday, July 1.

With summer officially upon us, plenty of time remains to help Bike Erie reach their 2015 National Bike Challenge goals. 

The High Priestess of Soul to be the focus of a new 100-minute documentary.

IN THIS ISSUE

We have a sincere offer to help revamp Celebrate Erie

Refugees find Erie's Preferred Community rating not very representative of Erie's desire to educate and hire recently relocated individuals.

The UPMC Sunset Music Series will host a display of some local country veterans and new kids on the block when Refuge and M4 hit the stage at Presque Isle Beach 1 Wednesday, July 1.

When the members of The Clarks come to the Burger King Amphitheatre Tuesday, July 7, they'll bring nearly 30 years of good ol' rock experience with them.

The three-day music festival kicks off July 3.

Innovation in and outside of the plastics industry makes Rehrig Pacific a business to be trusted in the Erie area.

Brooke Surgener, a member of the Reader's 2014 40 under 40 class, will show off her DIY attitude and musical talents at the Erie Art Museum's Mid-day Art Break Wednesday, July 1.

The King of Rock 'n' Roll is coming to the Erie Playhouse next week, in the form of the stage's latest fundraising event: Luigi Jannuzzi's All The King's Women.

Can the struggle for power in local government take a break so that change can be achieved?

"We are very stoked for our debut at the Kings Rook and look forward to an epic night full of dancing," MoChester guitarist/pianist/vocalist/cowbellist Jonathan Sheffer said.