Street Corner Soapbox: Nate Silver Wins!

Categories:  Street Corner Soapbox    News & Politics    Opinion
Wednesday, November 14th, 2012 at 11:00 AM
Street Corner Soapbox: Nate Silver Wins! by Jay Stevens

So, the election’s over, and Nate Silver won.

That’s right, the New York Times’ writer of its “Five Thirty Eight” blog won the election. He’s the poll analyzer who gave President Barack Obama a 90.9 percent chance of winning the election days before it happened, and who had been roundly criticized as being biased towards the president by conservative pundits. Cable-television pundit Joe Scarborough, for example, said of Silver, “anybody that thinks this race is anything but a tossup...is such an ideologue...they’re jokes.”

“If it’s one thing we know,” said Silver’s fellow Times columnist, David Brooks, “it’s that experts with fancy computer models are terrible at predicting the future.”

You know the rest of the story. Obama won by a large Electoral College margin -- 332 to 206 -- and even won the popular vote by several percentage points. And Nate Silver correctly predicted the outcome in all 50 states.

Republicans up to election night truly believed Silver had it all wrong. The Romney campaign’s internal polls showed a Romney victory, so much so that Mitt Romney neglected to pen a concession speech on Election Day and his staff had hired a fireworks company to put on an 8-minute show after his victory.

So...what’s the deal? How did Silver get it right, and others look at the data and get it wrong? It mostly comes down to how polls are conducted. Essentially, you call a bunch of people and record how they’re planning to vote, and then weigh those answers based on what demographic they’re in, and how likely and in what numbers those demographics will vote. Silver -- and most pollsters -- correctly predicted a high Democratic turnout, while Republican pollsters did the opposite.

Those pollsters took the same data Silver saw, but readjusted it to reflect what they thought the composition of the electorate would look like. And they were wrong. In fact, they were egregiously wrong. Self-identified Democrats still flocked to the polls in 2012 in nearly the same numbers as they did in 2008. Additionally, proportionally more Latinos, African-Americans, women, and young voters voted in 2012 than they did in 2008.

Basically, Republican pollsters and pundits looked at the polls, ignored whatever data defied their preconceived notion about the electorate, ran the numbers not through an algorithm or computer, but through their ideology, and came up wrong.

Because of the results, Silver’s enjoying deserved attention. Sales of his book, “The Signal and the Noise: Why So Many Predictions Fail -- But Some Don’t,” are taking off. Some are even saying that Silver’s predictions mean an end to punditry. Will all of the opinion-makers who said the American people were put off by Obama’s agenda be out of a job? Will those that foretold a conservative nation be forced to take unemployment?

Hardly. Remember, many of the highly-paid and -revered newspaper and cable television commentators -- David Brooks, for one -- were dangerously wrong on Iraq, and provided the “intellectual” basis for the war there. Yet they still work, despite the trillions of dollars and thousands of lives thrown down that rat hole.
Still, let’s hope that Silver’s election victory does alter the punditry landscape some, putting more pressure on these people to back assertions with facts, opinions with research, and ideas with merit. And then all of us will be winners.

Jay Stevens can be contacted at Jay@ErieReader.com.

Erie Reader: Vol. 4, No. 17
Now Available — Pick It Up Today

CURRENT

LEAF hosts its final Movie in the Arboretum this Friday. It's going to be a kickin' time.

Enjoy a Black & White Affair to celebrate the release of a new compilation involving some of Erie's most prolific independent artists.

Stories you may have missed from the Erie Reader Archive. This week: Is the "runway to somewhere, we hope," really a "bridge to nowhere?"

Fantasy/ Sci-fi fans, take note - the Screamicorn is here!

 

California punk band sells out.

IN THIS ISSUE

The Art of Patricia Kearney: Selected Work 1975-2013

Erie Man Returns to Troubled Homeland to Document Crisis

No Second Guessing The New Depression starts with circus-like fanfare, but there's no funny business after that – only serious rhymes layered upon thick, jazzy samples that don't neglect the booming bottom-end we all appreciate.

If you are an inveterate fan of New Jersey pop-punk quartet The Gaslight Anthem, you will likely be disappointed or at least befuddled by their latest release.

After releasing their debut album back in 2011, Buffalo-quartet The Albrights return with their self-titled sophomore release, and the results are as catchy as ever.

The sole founding members of Spoon have mastered the art of piecing together separate sonic parts to create a memorable whole, carefully constructing songs with basic elements before adding special touches through audio engineering tricks to dazzle all of the headphone listeners out there.

German Heritage Festival, Zabawa Polish Festival, and the Erie County Fair -- all happening in two weeks!

Unicorns and vampires? FILM's got you covered, Erie.

Two nights, two killer shows: Chrome Moses w/ Daybreak Radio, and The Burning River Ramblers at King’s Rook Club.

Seventy years ago, three Erie brothers gave the ultimate sacrifice.