The Way I See It: Privatizing Liquor Sales and the Millcreek School Board

Categories:      Opinion
Wednesday, February 6th, 2013 at 11:53 AM
The Way I See It: Privatizing Liquor Sales and the Millcreek School Board by Rebecca Styn
wikimedia commons

Privatizing Liquor

On Wednesday, Jan. 28, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett announced a plan to privatize liquor stores. Personally, I have always been a huge proponent of the privatization of liquor sales. As many of you know, Pennsylvania is fairly antiquated in many of its processes. In fact, we are only one of two states in the country that have fully state-controlled liquor systems – the other state being Utah.
So, why is this plan a good thing?

Welcome to Costco. I love you.

Privatizing the state’s liquor store system would open up sales to include convenience stores, pharmacies, supermarkets, and big-box retailers.

Taking care of business

This plan will help create opportunity for economic expansion for private sector employers while remaining revenue neutral for the state. Currently, there about 600 state stores in Pennsylvania and the governor’s plan allows for 1,200 wine and spirits stores.

Show me the money

Selling the state liquor stores will provide a boost to the state funds. Through this plan, Corbett has committed $1 billion in proceeds to put towards education funding. The $1 billion will be used to create the Passport for Learning Block Grant, which will provide flexibility to schools, allowing public schools – instead of Harrisburg – to decide what their students need. It will also focus on key priority areas, including individualized learning and science, school safety, enhanced early education, technology, engineering and mathematics courses and programs.

If anyone orders merlot, I’m leaving

Ever go to another state and find a wine brand that isn’t sold in Pennsylvania? I have. More often than not. With more stores selling and more competition between them, this will help create increased selection.

All opposed, say “aye”

Opponents have their say in this too. Those against the plan tout that a privatized system will increase drunk driving and underage drinking. To try to combat this, the governor’s plan calls for significantly enhanced fines for selling to minors and visibly intoxicated patrons, with penalties ranging upwards of $10,000.

There is also the potential for job loss.

The United Food and Commercial Workers Union Local 1776 support some 3,000 store employees who under a privatized system would lose jobs. The Liquor Control Board (LCB) currently employs about 5,000 people. However, Corbett notes that his plan includes measures for affected LCB employees, including tax credits for businesses that employ separated workers, educational credits, civil service credits, individual employment plans, and ways to help displaced employees find re-employment.

It’s often been said, that private industry tends to run a better business than government. And I think it’s time we explored this further.

In the dark

I’m sure you’ve heard by now that Millcreek School Superintendent Michael Golde is out on administrative leave citing “personal reasons.” This is obviously pertinent news given all the backlash that the Millcreek School Board has received since they approved a $91-million renovation project.

Part of the speculation for Golde’s leave was tied to an audit report that the board had been keeping under wraps. However, on Monday, Jan. 27, the board officially released the audit.

According to WICU12 news reports, the audit, which was completed by the firm of Felix and Gloekler, shows the school district ended the 2012 school year with a $3.5-million deficit, at a time when some school officials and taxpayers believed there was a surplus. It also states that last July 23, someone approved the transfer of $5-million from a capital projects fund to the general operations fund. However, the funds were replaced on Oct. 22, 2012 after the audit was underway.

But there could be a cost.  Bond proceeds in the public arena are tax exempt and moving them could impact that status and result in a fine from the IRS.

But the biggest issue may be the failure of checks and balances that permitted the transfer.

As of today, the public hasn’t been allowed to ask any questions about Golde’s leave. Preceding a closed-door executive session on Jan. 22, the board banned public comment during their open personnel committee meeting.

Just for comparison purposes, on Nov. 20, the Iroquois School Board put Superintendent Sam Signorino on paid leave pending the results of a Board investigation. While the board didn’t give details at the time, the public claimed during a board meeting that Signorino had used a district garage to restore a classic car. The public was also invited to share information that was factual and relevant to the investigation with the board and its attorney.

The school directors ultimately found no wrongdoing by Signorino, and the school board president took responsibility for giving Signorino permission to use the garage without consulting the rest of the School Board. However, Signorino and the board president ultimately resigned.

So if one school district respects the public’s right to know, shouldn’t the other? I mean, what’s good for the goose is good for the gander, right?

Love? Hate? Agree? Disagree? I want to hear from you. Email me at and follow me on Twitter at @rStyn.


Erie Reader: Vol. 7, No. 21
Now Available — Pick It Up Today


Video of the debates at the Jefferson Educational Society

A short interview with the Delaware post-hardcore band. 

Opening the lid on a Hallo-wealth of activities 


An exit interview with outgoing Erie Mayor Joe Sinnott



Bolero’s flavors dance the fandango in your mouth


Opening the lid on a Hallo-wealth of activities 


An exit interview with outgoing Erie Mayor Joe Sinnott



Bolero’s flavors dance the fandango in your mouth

Best-selling Author to discuss works at Mercyhurst

Anime convention sharpening up for fifth year

Thankfully, as the title implies, this kind of pop is surviving.

Personal confessions of a Rocky-addled mind

Artists reflect on their favorite compositions

We are gonna miss you

Tropidelic will be headlining a show for those who wish to get down to some rhythmic funk.