Search ErieReader.com
DonateBest of Erie40 Under 40TicketsAdvertiseDistributionIssuesAboutContactEventsNewsletter
Close
Donate!
Best of Erie 2026
40 Under 40
The Reader Beat
Tickets
Newsletter Signup
Erie Reader Business Quarterly
City Guide
Events
Opinion
Features
Issues Archive
Events Calendar
Advertise
More
Arts & Culture
Business
Columns
Community
Environment
Film
From the Editors
Gem City Style
Local, Original Comics
Music Reviews
News & Politics
Recipes
Sports
Theater
Distribution Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Issue Archives
Internship Opportunities
Write for Us
Share:
Movie Reviews

"Then You Can Start to Make it Better": Yesterday Doesn't Make the Most of Its Concept

by Forest Taylor
View ProfileRSS Feed
July 3, 2019 at 10:15 AM

The Beatles are now so firmly entrenched in popular culture that it's almost impossible to imagine what popular music would be like without their influence. Mythologized and deified seemingly into eternity, a vast majority of people would argue that they are the greatest songwriters in history. Thus, Danny Boyle's (Trainspotting, Slumdog Millionaire) new film Yesterday asks a very intriguing question: What if The Beatles suddenly didn't exist anymore? The film briefly touches on the implications of this ingenious concept before settling comfortably in romantic comedy cliches (it is, after all, penned by Love Actually's Richard Curtis).

The film follows young Jack Malick (Himesh Patel), a struggling musician who gets into a bad accident only to wake up in a world where only he seems to remember the existence of The Beatles and their music. Jack now finds himself in an interesting moral predicament: "write" all the band's hit songs and pass them off as his own (along with all the fame and money that comes with them) at the expense of knowing that he's stealing from his favorite band.

As I said before, the premise is a brilliant one; is it morally right to commit a massive act of plagiarism when nobody but the perpetrator is aware that it's plagiarism? The film also has fun playing with the idea of The Beatles writing their music in today's age of commercialized pop. Would their songs even be the same? These are great ideas that get dropped completely to settle for a nice little feel-good conclusion. It's not all bad as the characters are likable and well-written, but the third act feels like a waste of all the fascinating ideas that came before. — Forest Taylor

Directed by Danny Boyle // Written by: Richard Curtis // Starring: Himesh Patel, Lily James, Joel Fry, Kate McKinnon, Alexander Arnold, Sophia Di Martino, Ellise Chappell, Harry Michell, Meera Syal, Sanjeev Bhaskar, and Ed Sheeran // 116 minutes // Rated PG-13

The BeatlesYesterday

Featured Events

Today Tomorrow This Weekend

Canapes & Cocktails

Food & Drink
Nov. 17th, 6 PM

Beginner Basket Class with Dan Bainbridge: Part III: Weave Harder

Education & Instruction
Nov. 17th, 6 PM

A Post Election Conversation With Margaret Hoover

Community & Causes
Nov. 17th, 7 PM to 8:30 PM

Hot Water Music! Live at Centennial Hall

Music
Nov. 18th, 6:30 PM

Music Bingo At Altered State Distillery

Hobbies & Interests
Nov. 19th, 12 PM to 2 PM

Submit Your Event   View Calendar

November 2026: Shop Local
Erie Reader: Vol. 16, No. 11
View Past Issues
In This Issue
Erie Reader Best of Erie City Guide 2023-2026

Popular This Week

COVID-19 Cases Rise Slightly In Erie County, Across Country

xRepresentx, Vice, Counterfeit, Cop Torture at BT

Ludacris Shows Behrend Some Southern Hospitality

Best of Erie 2014 Finalists

Hangin' Out at the South Pier

Related Articles

Love of Your Life is Effective, but Nothing Groundbreaking

by Forest Taylor11/6/2026, 12:00 PM
Bring it back

You Can See Everything Is One of the Most Fascinating Documentaries Ever Made

by Forest Taylor11/5/2026, 12:00 PM
The medium is the message

Five Films to Watch For From TIFF 2026

by Forest Taylor10/13/2026, 8:00 AM
The 51st Toronto Film Festival offers some gems of world cinema

Coyote vs. Acme is a Minor Miracle

by Forest Taylor9/4/2026, 12:00 PM
That's all folks!

Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma is Messy in All the Best Ways

by Forest Taylor9/3/2026, 3:00 PM
Scream queen

Maddie's Secret is a Camp Spectacle

by Forest Taylor8/8/2026, 9:00 AM
Woman, interrupted
Member of Reporters Shield
© 2026 Great Lakes Online Media
PO Box 10963  //  Erie, PA 16514
Editorial Standards Terms of Use Privacy Policy