Search ErieReader.com
DonateBest of Erie40 Under 40TicketsAdvertiseDistributionIssuesAboutContactEventsNewsletter
Close
Donate!
Best of Erie 2026
40 Under 40
The Reader Beat
Tickets
Newsletter Signup
Erie Reader Business Quarterly
City Guide
Events
Opinion
Features
Issues Archive
Events Calendar
Advertise
More
Arts & Culture
Business
Columns
Community
Environment
Film
From the Editors
Gem City Style
Local, Original Comics
Music Reviews
News & Politics
Recipes
Sports
Theater
Distribution Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Issue Archives
Internship Opportunities
Write for Us
Share:
Spotlight Events

Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 Brings Timeless Humor Thanks to Confident Cast

by Hannah McDonald
View ProfileLinkedInRSS Feed
February 12, 2019 at 12:15 PM
Photos by Julia Kramer

Thursday, Feb. 14

The quick wit and eccentric caricature of the actors in The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 carry the show smoothly through its nearly two-hour run time. The play, opening at Edinboro University's Diebold Performing Arts Center on Valentine's Day, is entirely student-run and "not your typical murder mystery," Director Torie Witherow said. "It takes your typical tropes and turns them on their heads."

Originally written and directed by John Bishop, the play gained critical attention and acclaim after it premiered in New York City in the late '80s, later becoming a Broadway success under its original director and cast.

Though previewed on the first day of tech week while set changes were still being made, the cast has already boldly stepped into their roles, confident in both persona and lines.

The arrangement of said cast is almost as unique as the twists and turns Bishop took with the script. In The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940, there are no leads. Each actor and their corresponding character play a critical role in the story. No one role is more influential or important to the play than another, Witherow explained.

This said, the collegiate cast has talent that stands out, even in such a strong group. Elsa Von Grossenknueten, the wealthy theater-lover who brings the characters together to her upstate mansion for a backers audition, is played by Elise Cohen, whose voice projects clear as glass in the black box theater. Mason Kuhr, playing the role of Eddie the comedian, keeps all eyes on him with his theatrical and genuinely funny facial expressions and body language. Rich Kolbosky impersonates the arrogance necessary for Ken, a successful theater (and recently cinema) director. And Helsa, Elise's German housemaid, has an accent that never breaks or falters thanks to Livia Homerski.

The remainder of the 11-person cast is filled by Abby Ricci as Nicki, Lamont Jones as police officer Michael Kelly, Hope Errera as Bernice, Sydney Dobbs as Ruth, Gwen Bogaczyk as Marjorie and Mikhail Firree as O'Reilly who has the ability to make the audience just the slightest bit uncomfortable with his awkward advances on Helsa.

"I've done comedies hundreds of times...and seen this show countless times, and I'm still laughing," Witherow said.

The show is "as historically accurate as we can afford," assured the director, referencing the period respective costumes and set pieces. In addition to the antique props and dress, the sets itself uses details — such as secret passageways — to bring the show to life.

Though Edinboro University no longer hosts any academic minors or majors in theater, "I want to show the community that we're still here...and willing to put on a great show for them," Witherow said.

If you're wondering if you should brave the weather to watch comedy theater about theater in a snowstorm, take advice from the ever-energetic Eddie: "Sure! That's one of my rules; Always say, 'yes!'"

While tickets are only available at the door, reservations can be made by calling Witherow, who advises audience members to bring cash for a smoother experience. — Hannah McDonald

7:30 p.m. Feb. 14 - 16, 21 - 23, 2:30 p.m. Feb. 24 // Diebold Center for the Performing Arts, 217 Meadville St Edinboro // $10 general admission, $3 for EU Students, $5 for EU Faculty, Staff, Seniors and other students // facebook.com/EdinboroUniversityTheatre

Recommended Event

The Musical Comedy of Murders 1940

Performing Arts
11/19/2026
The creative team behind a recent Broadway flop (in which three chorus girls were mysteriously murdered) assemble for a backer's audition of their new show at the Westchester estate of a wealthy ec...
Edinboro UniversityJohn BishopBroadway showcomedy theaterdiebold performing arts center

Featured Events

Today Tomorrow This Weekend

Art History Evening At The Neighborhood Art House

Visual Arts
Nov. 19th, 6 PM to 8 PM

The Author Of Autocracy Inc. On How Dictators Are Working Together To Run The World

Community & Causes
Nov. 19th, 7 PM to 8:30 PM

Over the Tavern

Performing Arts
Nov. 19th, 7:30 PM

Downtown d'Lights 2026

Kids/Family
Nov. 20th, 5 PM to 8:30 PM

Hiroe

Music
Nov. 20th, 6 PM

Submit Your Event   View Calendar

November 2026: Shop Local
Erie Reader: Vol. 16, No. 11
View Past Issues
In This Issue
Erie Reader Best of Erie City Guide 2023-2026

Popular This Week

COVID-19 Cases Rise Slightly In Erie County, Across Country

xRepresentx, Vice, Counterfeit, Cop Torture at BT

Ludacris Shows Behrend Some Southern Hospitality

Best of Erie 2014 Finalists

Hangin' Out at the South Pier

Related Articles

Downtown d'Lights Kicks Off Earlier in Season

by Gretchen Gallagher-Durney11/13/2026, 10:00 AM
Annual tree lighting and activities in Perry Square

Erie Reader Book Club: Strange as This Weather Has Been by Ann Pancake

by Ally Kutz11/11/2026, 10:00 AM
Shop Local choice for November meeting

WQLN Holiday Craft Show

by Edwina Capozziello11/10/2026, 10:00 AM
The annual event is back at Rainbow Gardens to help you get into the spirit of the season

Erie Philharmonic Reunites with Joyce Yang for Gershwin Swings

by Thomas Taylor11/9/2026, 11:00 AM
With Carlos Simon bridging culture and social justice with orchestration

Find Your Way to PACA for Lost, Then Found in the Middle of Gnowarre

by Cara Suppa11/9/2026, 10:00 AM
Original cast members reprise roles in local favorite

Classical Music Meets Hip-Hop with Black Violin

by Erica Stewart11/6/2026, 10:00 AM
The Be Free Tour makes stop at Mercyhurst University
Member of Reporters Shield
© 2026 Great Lakes Online Media
PO Box 10963  //  Erie, PA 16514
Editorial Standards Terms of Use Privacy Policy