Erie Reader Files Lawsuit Seeking Millcreek Flock Data
The Reader goes to court after request for license plate reader data is rejected
On Nov. 13, the Erie Reader and I, represented by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press (RCFP), filed a petition for review in the Erie County Court of Common Pleas in pursuit of the release of Millcreek Township's Flock Safety automated license plate reader (ALPR) data. The Reader is the petitioner in this case; the Millcreek Township Police Department (MTPD) is the respondent.
The MTPD has been given 20 days to respond to the filing. As of Nov. 16, they have yet to respond.
On Aug. 26, I filed a Right-to-Know Law (RTKL) request for the aggregated data and organizational audit data from January 2026 through August 2026 via the Flock camera database at the Millcreek Mall, including search reasons, devices, and officer names. Aggregated data is the result of individual data points combined into a summary so that it is not possible to distinguish or identify those data points.
Following a 30-day extension, Millcreek police Capt. Christopher Hauber, the township's open records officer, denied my request. He wrote that the data "may pertain to a record of the department relating to and resulting in a criminal investigation." I then appealed directly to the Pennsylvania Office of Open Records (OOR), which dismissed my request on the grounds that the records relate to alleged criminal investigations and that the OOR lacks jurisdiction over these records.
MTPD has access to five ALPR cameras around the Millcreek Mall property. Residents have repeatedly raised concerns about Flock's security and the township's transparency at Millcreek Township Board of Supervisors meetings. "We should be absolutely scrupulous in our collaborations and in the tools that we are using in law enforcement to create trust in our community," said Alice Edwards, a Millcreek resident for 34 years, during the July 28 Board of Supervisors meeting.
According to reports from earlier meetings, the contract between the Cafaro Co., owner of the Millcreek Mall, and Flock was set to automatically renew on Nov. 1 unless Cafaro or Millcreek Township moved to cancel it within 30 days of renewal. Neither Cafaro nor Millcreek Township made a move to end the contract, so it continues under the same conditions.
Paula Knudsen Burke, a Pennsylvania-based attorney for the RCFP, wrote in a statement: "This type of technology has raised considerable questions from the public, and Pennsylvania's public records law, the Right to Know Law, allows requesters to find out more information about taxpayer-funded equipment such as ALPRs." The Millcreek Mall cameras are owned by Cafaro and MTPD accesses their data under the township's license agreement.
Ours is not the first case in Pennsylvania that Burke and her team have litigated over Flock data. In Lehigh County, Morning Call reporter Lindsay Weber filed a Right-to-Know request seeking Allentown's aggregated ALPR data, which the city denied. "[Weber v. City of Allentown] is pending in the Lehigh County Court of Common Pleas," said Burke. "We look forward to presenting our arguments in court."
Editor's note: The Erie Reader is a plaintiff in this case. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press also represented the Reader in Laughlin v. The Erie Reader.

