CalendarAdvertiseDistributionArchiveAboutContact
Close
News & Politics
Events
Music
Arts & Culture
Opinion
Food & Drink
Web Only
More
Business
Community
Environment
Erie at Large
Erie Faces Erie
Features
Film
From the Editors
Harrisburg Happenings
Jen Sorensen Cartoons
Just a Thought
Just Toyin' Witcha
Music Reviews
News of the Weird
Sports
Theater
Events Calendar
Advertise
Distribution Locations
Issues Archive
Shop
About Us
Contact Us
Share:
BloggERy

Romney Nails It: Health Care Reform is "Fundamentally Conservative"

Romney's enemies mock the candidate for calling health reform "fundamentally conservative." There's one problem: he's right.

by Jay Stevens
View ProfileFacebookTwitterGoogle+RSS Feed
December 28, 2011 at 7:19 PM
MittRomneyCentral.com

In a recent interview, presidential hopeful Mitt Romney called the Massachusetts health care policy passed during his gubernatorial stint over that state -- and which was mirrored in the recent health care bill passed by Congress -- "fundamentally conservative."

Naturally, conservative bloggers repulsed by Romney's suspect political history -- he was, at one time, pro-choice, among other heretical stances -- were all over this comment. Many think the health care reform is socialistic or whatever slur-du-jour they employ, in large part because of the individual mandate forcing consumers to purchase insurance or be fined by the federal government.

  • The Gateway Pundit's Jim Hoft: "Mitt Rommey says forcing Americans to buy a product in a conservative principle."
     
  • Red State's Erick Erickson: "...the conservative solution is not to force Americans to buy a product. Forcing Americans, through penalty of law, into purchasing or refraining from purchasing a product is not and will never be conservative."
     
  • Hot Air's Tina Korbe: "...advocates of the individual mandate succumb to cynicism about the individual's ability to take care of himself. A mandate, in other words, proceeds from an elitist, bureaucratic assumption that government leaders know what individuals need even more than those individuals do."

First, Romney didn't actually say forcing people to buy insurance was fundamentally conservative. He said forcing people to buy private insurance was fundamentally conservative.

Second, the individual mandate -- forcing people to buy a product -- is a fundamentally conservative idea:

The concept of the individual health insurance mandate originated in 1989 at the conservative Heritage Foundation. In 1993, Republicans twice introduced health care bills that contained an individual health insurance mandate. Advocates for those bills included prominent Republicans who today oppose the mandate including Orrin Hatch (R-UT), Charles Grassley (R-IA), Robert Bennett (R-UT), and Christopher Bond (R-MO). In 2007, Democrats and Republicans introduced a bi-partisan bill containing the mandate.

In 2008, then presidential candidate Barack Obama was opposed to the individual mandate.

Heck, if you go back and read those Heritage Foundation documents -- from a very conservative think tank -- you'll see the basic principles at the heart of the recent health care bill: An individual mandate. Subsidies for low-income people to purchase insurance. An opening of the health-care market to foster competition.

That's pretty much the health-care bill.

And that's pretty much why the health-care bill is deeply flawed and won't fix the big problem of health care: rising costs. Basically it bribes the private insurers into taking care of our sick by dumping taxpayer money into the industry and forcing the young and healthy into the market. There are no cost controls. There are no employer mandates or public insurance options. There's no implementation of fee structures, no challenge to privately-run medical groups practice of fee-for-service charges, no end to the inherent and costly belief in moral hazard in medicine.

"Fundamentally conservative" sounds right to me.

Featured Events

Today Tomorrow This Weekend

2018 Erie County Democratic Party Spring Dinner

Food & Drink
Apr. 19th, 6:30 PM to 9:30 PM

Pains and Church Tongue

Music
Apr. 19th, 7 PM to 11 PM

Kountry Wayne

Community
Apr. 19th, 7 PM

Gov't Mule

Music
Apr. 19th, 7:30 PM

One Man, Two Guvnors

Theater
Apr. 19th, 8 PM

Submit Your Event   View Calendar

The Erie Art Museum Spring Show
Erie Reader: Vol. 8, No. 8
View Past Issues
In This Issue

Popular This Week

Millcreek Teachers' Baseball Bats Make Global Headlines

The Human Experience

Three Dems Debate for Erie's New Congressional District

Aqueous Expects More Highs for the Rook on 4/20

A Momentous Milestone For a Local Art Treasure

Related Articles

Tiger Maple String Band is spending St. Patrick's at Sprague's

by Ryan Smith3/17/2017, 5:04 AM
DD ... check. Go get some of your Patty's on at Sprague Farm and Brew Works!

Looking for a scary good time?

by Ryan Smith10/31/2016, 12:42 PM
Get your Halloween Night fright on at Ghost Lake.

Shining on the last night of Night Lights

by Ryan Smith8/27/2016, 12:00 PM
A quick Q-and-A with one of the festival's mainstay favorites: Aqueous

Shining (even more) on Night Lights Music Festival

by Ryan Smith8/26/2016, 3:04 PM
A quick Q-and-A with one of the festival's amazing performers: Tyler Smilo of Daybreak Radio

Shining (some more) on Night Lights Music Festival

by Ryan Smith8/25/2016, 5:06 PM
A quick Q-and-A with one of the festival's amazing bands: GNOSiS

Shining on Night Lights Music Festival

by Ryan Smith8/24/2016, 5:44 AM
A quick Q-and-A with one of the festival's chief founders, organizers, and musicians: Scott Molloy
© 2018 Great Lakes Online Media
1001 State Street  //  Erie, PA 16501
Terms of Use Privacy Policy