Search ErieReader.com
DonateBest of Erie40 Under 40TicketsAdvertiseDistributionIssuesAboutContactEventsNewsletter
Close
Donate!
Best of Erie 2026
40 Under 40
The Reader Beat
Tickets
Newsletter Signup
Erie Reader Business Quarterly
City Guide
Events
Opinion
Features
Issues Archive
Events Calendar
Advertise
More
Arts & Culture
Business
Columns
Community
Environment
Film
From the Editors
Gem City Style
Local, Original Comics
Music Reviews
News & Politics
Recipes
Sports
Theater
Distribution Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Issue Archives
Internship Opportunities
Write for Us
Share:
OpinionNews and Politics

Street Corner Soapbox: The Teaching of Creationism in Pennsylvania

Why it's not intelligent to be teaching intelligent design in science classes in Pa.

by Jay Stevens
View ProfileFacebookTwitterGoogle+RSS Feed
October 2, 2013 at 7:51 AM

In a recent guest editorial for the Erie Times-News, member of the Louisiana Coalition for Science, Barbara Forrest, warned that religious conservatives were working to bring creationism back to Pennsylvania schools.

"With intelligent design exposed as creationism in court," she wrote, speaking of a landmark decision in which intelligent design – the belief that an intelligent creator best explains the composition of the universe – was found to be a form of religious indoctrination, not science, "the Discovery Institute now conceals its true aims behind the sanitized code language of 'academic freedom' legislation, seeking to undermine the teaching of evolution under the guise of 'critical thinking.'"

Forrest refers specifically to a bill sponsored by state House Representative Stephen Bloom of North Middleton Township, the text of which sounds innocuous enough. The state, says the bill, will be obligated to help teachers present a curriculum around "scientific controversies," and allow teachers to "help students understand, analyze, critique and review in an objective manner the scientific strengths and scientific weaknesses of existing scientific theories."

In an interview with Harrisburg's paper, The Patriot-News, Bloom defended his bill from critics. "Teachers are intimidated to the point where they can't even bring up criticisms in the classroom," he said. "To me, that's not good science."

But, of course, the bill is anything but innocuous, and does not in any way promote "good science."

Start with this fact: A considerable percentage of Pennsylvania high-school teachers are creationists. A national survey found that 13 percent of 900 polled science teachers believe the Earth is less than 10,000 years old, and a recent Pittsburgh Post-Gazette survey found that nearly 20 percent of polled Pennsylvania science teachers believe in creationism.

These are the beneficiaries of Bloom's "academic freedom," not Pennsylvania students or science. Bloom's bill would enable these teachers to wander off the Pennsylvania science curriculum and teach their beliefs, which are bad science.

And that's the important thing in this debate. Evolution, climate change, and other "controversial" scientific theories are created in the intellectual lab of the scientific method – the idea that understanding should derive from measurable, empirical evidence. That practice is the central goal of science education. Those theories labeled "controversial" are so only if you view them through the lens of political ideology or fundamentalist religious belief – not science.

"A politically-motivated, decades-long war on expertise has eroded the popular consensus on a wide variety of scientifically validated topics," wrote PopularScience.com's online content director, Suzanne LaBarre, on her site's decision to remove comments sections from all future articles. "Everything from evolution to the origins of climate change is mistakenly up for grabs again. Scientific certainty is just another thing for two people to 'debate' on television."

The idea that science should be subjected to a kind of "fairness" – which is essentially what Representative Bloom's "academic freedom" bill is asking – is dead wrong. You can't balance scientific consensus with popular opinion, scientific theory with religious belief, fact with fiction.

Teaching creationism, questioning scientific theories with questionable rhetorical fallacies, promoting pseudo-scientific "theories," promoting belief over science – that's not science. That's political and religious indoctrination, and has no place in our schools' science classrooms.

Jay Stevens can be contacted at Jay@ErieReader.com, and you can follow him on Twitter @Snevets_Yaj. 

creationismintelligent designstephen bloomteacherspennsylvania teachers

Featured Events

Today Tomorrow This Weekend

Over the Tavern

Performing Arts
Nov. 22nd, 2 PM

Erie Otters Home Game

Sports
Nov. 25th, 7 PM

AHN Saint Vincent Festival Of Trees

Kids/Family
Nov. 27th, 9 AM to 8 PM

This American Song Vinyl Release Show

Music
Nov. 27th, 6 PM

Definitely Not the Original ( Cover Night!! 21+ )

Music
Nov. 27th, 8 PM

Submit Your Event   View Calendar

November 2026: Shop Local
Erie Reader: Vol. 16, No. 11
View Past Issues
In This Issue
Erie Reader Best of Erie City Guide 2023-2026

Popular This Week

COVID-19 Cases Rise Slightly In Erie County, Across Country

xRepresentx, Vice, Counterfeit, Cop Torture at BT

Ludacris Shows Behrend Some Southern Hospitality

Best of Erie 2014 Finalists

Hangin' Out at the South Pier

Related Articles

Erie Reader Files Lawsuit Seeking Millcreek Flock Data

by Alana Sabol11/16/2026, 3:45 PM
The Reader goes to court after request for license plate reader data is rejected

Blue Tsunami Reaches PA, but Not the 16th District

by Alana Sabol11/4/2026, 2:00 PM
Democrats win Congress and a Harrisburg trifecta as Justin Wagner falls short

Michelle Obama Speaks at JES Global Summit

by Alana Sabol10/20/2026, 2:00 PM
The former First Lady shares messages of hope in difficult times

Justin Wagner: The Democratic Candidate of District 16

by Alana Sabol10/12/2026, 3:00 PM
Wagner faces off against Rep. Mike Kelly in November midterms

Returning Ready to Learn

by Natalyn Gibbs, Ed.D., superintendent and CEO of Erie's Public Schools9/3/2026, 9:00 AM
How Erie's Public Schools and families build a future-ready Erie

Making a Small City Smaller: Giving in A Small City

by Dave Tamulonis8/11/2026, 10:00 AM
How Erie's unique giving culture sustains a robust nonprofit sector
Member of Reporters Shield
© 2026 Great Lakes Online Media
PO Box 10963  //  Erie, PA 16514
Editorial Standards Terms of Use Privacy Policy