Mayor Bloomberg: Go Occupy the Poorhouse!

Category:  BloggERy
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 at 8:02 PM
Mayor Bloomberg: Go Occupy the Poorhouse! by Jay Stevens
The Village Voice

It's a favorite topic of mainstream media pundits and, frankly, a lot of frustrated voters: we need a third political party!  A great idea, right? So, why haven't any emerged, if everyone wants one?

Well, today Michael Bloomberg gives us the answer. You know, the same Mayor Bloomberg that Unity08 nearly put foward as a presidential candidate -- and Unity08 the project that wanted to put a "bipartisan" candidate in office to counter, you know, the partisan bickering in Washington DC and, you know, get things done!

Anyway, obviously frustrated by the Occupy Wall Street protest in his city, Bloomberg had this to say:

It was not the banks that created the mortgage crisis. It was, plain and simple, Congress who forced everybody to go and give mortgages to people who were on the cusp....But they were the ones who pushed Fannie and Freddie to make a bunch of loans that were imprudent, if you will. They were the ones that pushed the banks to loan to everybody.

Look familiar? It should. It's the Rush-Limbaugh-wing of the GOP's response to the mortgage crisis. Essentially, goes the argument, the blame lies with the federal goverment for lending money for housing to low-income families in inner-city areas; those people couldn't pay their mortgages and started the housing crash. (Think of it as "those-lazy-brown-people-tanked-the-economy' argument.)

Only it isn't true.

Barry Ritholz, via Mother Jones:

 

  • The origination of subprime loans came primarily from non-bank lenders not covered by the [Community Reinvestment Act, a law pushing the two GSEs to purchase more loans in the secondary markets and thus expand access to housing loans to low-income neighborhoods];
     
  • The majority of the underwriting, at least for the first few years of the boom, were by these same non-bank lenders;
     
  • When the big banks began chasing subprime, it was due to the profit motive, not any mandate from the President (a Republican) or the Congress (Republican controlled) or the GSEs they oversaw;
     
  • Prior to 2005, nearly all of these sub-prime loans were bought by Wall Street—NOT Fannie & Freddie;
     
  • In fact, prior to 2005, the GSEs were not permitted to purchase non-conforming mortgages;
     
  • The change in FNM/FRE conforming mortgage purchases in 2005 was not due to any legislation or marching orders from the President (a Republican) or the the Congress (Republican controlled). It was the profit motive that led them to this action.

Get it? Subprime mortgages were rushed to market for profitmotives by banks that weren't required to lend money to low- or middle-income families under the Community Reinvestment Act.

These are facts so apparent, that either Bloomberg is an idiot, or he's knowingly riding on right-wing talk-show rhetoric. Lying. Either way, it's a stark reminder of the mayor's political position as a "fiscal conservative," or big-business conservative. He's a champion of Wall Street. A man who engineered big tax breaks for the city's financial industry.

He's also socially liberal. Pro-choice. Favors gay marriage. Smoked pot, and liked it. In the world of the mainstream media, that makes him a "centrist," a guy to get behind.

But that's imagining the political spectrum simplistically in terms of Red v Blue, Democrat v Republican. Unfortunately (or fortunately if you're a fan of human complexity), the array of political opinions in the country are wide and multi-faceted. Some Christian conservatives are anti-corporate environmentalists. Some union members oppose gay marriage, or even interracial marriage.

That is, you can pit the electorate against itself in many varied combinations, but one of the most potent is pro-corporate v populist. And the pro-corporate side of the equation is very small. 


Erie Reader: Vol. 4, No. 19
Now Available — Pick It Up Today

CURRENT

All's quiet on the homefront going into this week, but big things are happening in the international community. Are you up to speed? 

CBS's Bob Schieffer attacks Congressional cowardice. Hint: He's not wrong. 

The public has spoken on net neutrality. Now we wait to see if the FCC was listenting.  

Scottish referendum ends in peaceful acceptance of the status quo. 

Apple wants you to want them, even if you don't love the free gift. 

IN THIS ISSUE

A look at The Unholy Murder of Ash Wednesday.

Erie’s USPS mail-sorting facility is on the chopping block, again.

The Violent Nature of the NFL and the Business of Football.

It's time we look in the mirror and stop saying "if-only."

MIAC brings gifted storyteller, singer-songwriter to Erie.

Erie's Y-Co Dances, circa the '60s, have made a comeback.

A look at the upcoming season -- plus a film twelve years in the making.

Two former Colonels have made the news, and we're pretty excited about it. 

The harrassment of women in the gaming industry.

Welcome to a whole new level of the King's Rook Club