Seth Avett and Jessica Lea Mayfield // Sing Elliott Smith

Category:  Music Reviews
Wednesday, March 18th, 2015 at 8:15 AM
Seth Avett and Jessica Lea Mayfield // Sing Elliott Smith by Alex Bieler

Seth Avett and Jessica Lea Mayfield

Seth Avett and Jessica Lea Mayfield Sing Elliott Smith

Ramseur Records

3 stars

It can be hard to change something that’s already great. It’s an issue that Seth Avett of The Avett Brothers fame and the Ohio-based singer-songwriter seemed to encounter when they teamed up to cover a selection of songs by Elliot Smith, a beloved musician who died from self-inflicted wounds in 2003. The unsurprisingly-titled Seth Avett and Jessica Lea Mayfield Sing Elliot Smith features the sweet-voiced duo’s take on a dozen of their favorite Smith tracks, which aren’t all that different from the originals. In fact, Sing Elliot Smith is a very appropriate name given that the only real differences in the songs happen to be Avett and Mayfield’s vocal work. The results are awfully pretty and entirely enjoyable, but you’ll likely find yourself yearning for the magic in Smith’s original works instead of these overly loyal recreations. There’s nothing particularly bad about the album – in fact, it’s pretty lovely at times – but it doesn’t really provide anything that essential. – Alex Bieler

Erie Reader: Vol. 7, No. 13
Now Available — Pick It Up Today

CURRENT

Dr. Ferki Ferati will succeed Dr. William P. Gary as the head of Erie's think tank

Innovators, entrepreneurs, and leaders shaping the future of Erie

Centenarian building serves criminally good drinks, eats

Thousands of music enthusiasts from all across the country flock to the Great Blue Heron Music Festival.

Don’t Blink Photography and Design along with The Box will is putting together Humanity Against Heroin fundraiser.

IN THIS ISSUE

Innovators, entrepreneurs, and leaders shaping the future of Erie

Centenarian building serves criminally good drinks, eats

Thousands of music enthusiasts from all across the country flock to the Great Blue Heron Music Festival.

Don’t Blink Photography and Design along with The Box will is putting together Humanity Against Heroin fundraiser.

Big Thief are able to communicate emotions with heartbreaking accuracy.

East High School Tribute

Uncanny advertising and meth-fueled hotwiring 

Catch some of Erie’s best original musicians while helping to support a great cause.

Goodell Gardens and friends present the gardens’ third annual Botanical Beverages event.

Beach Fossils continue to raise the bar for themselves