Search ErieReader.com
DonateBest of Erie40 Under 40TicketsAdvertiseDistributionIssuesAboutContactEventsNewsletter
Close
Donate!
Best of Erie 2026
40 Under 40
The Reader Beat
Tickets
Newsletter Signup
Erie Reader Business Quarterly
City Guide
Events
Opinion
Features
Issues Archive
Events Calendar
Advertise
More
Arts & Culture
Business
Columns
Community
Environment
Film
From the Editors
Gem City Style
Local, Original Comics
Music Reviews
News & Politics
Recipes
Sports
Theater
Distribution Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Issue Archives
Internship Opportunities
Write for Us
Share:
Book and LiteratureReviews

A Flaw in the Design

Nathan Oates' latest will keep your gears turning

by Ally Kutz
View ProfileRSS Feed
April 12, 2023 at 12:00 PM
Random House

Gil's life has been idyllic for more than a decade: after making the move from New York City to the countryside of Vermont and becoming an English professor at a local college, he now lives a peaceful life with his wife and two daughters — until his nephew comes to stay. In Nathan Oates' A Flaw in the Design, fiction and fact blur together to create a suspenseful mystery where not everything is as it seems.

When Gil's estranged sister and brother-in-law die in a mysterious accident, Gil is surprised to find that they've left guardianship of their teenage son Matthew to him, the very culprit behind the falling out between Gil and his sister seven years prior.

Now seemingly changed, Matthew shows little of the sinister child he used to be, instead putting forth a persona of ease and charm, lulling those around him into a false sense of security. Gil, however, still harbors some guilt as well as anger toward the boy, not forgetting the day in which he put his daughter's life in danger.

Although he hopes to put the past behind them, Gil starts to suspect ulterior motives when Matthew enrolls in one of his creative writing classes and begins turning in disturbing stories with details that are too close for comfort. When it seems that things may progress further, Gil feels he must take matters into his own hands in order to protect himself and his family, and expose the truth about his nephew.

While unreliable narrators are often used in the suspense genre, in this case it is up to the reader to determine how much or how little stock to put in each of the characters in Oates' novel. Employing third-person narration throughout, Oates carefully crafts a mind-bending thought puzzle, leading readers down a rabbit hole of paranoia surrounding Gil and Matthew.

Written in compulsive prose and with the makings of a one-session read, Nathan Oates' A Flaw in the Design will keep gears turning and minds thinking up until the very end. 

Random House // 304 pages // Thriller, Mystery

Book ReviewA Flaw in the DesignNathan Oates

Featured Events

Today Tomorrow This Weekend

Canapes & Cocktails

Food & Drink
Nov. 17th, 6 PM

Beginner Basket Class with Dan Bainbridge: Part III: Weave Harder

Education & Instruction
Nov. 17th, 6 PM

A Post Election Conversation With Margaret Hoover

Community & Causes
Nov. 17th, 7 PM to 8:30 PM

Hot Water Music! Live at Centennial Hall

Music
Nov. 18th, 6:30 PM

Music Bingo At Altered State Distillery

Hobbies & Interests
Nov. 19th, 12 PM to 2 PM

Submit Your Event   View Calendar

November 2026: Shop Local
Erie Reader: Vol. 16, No. 11
View Past Issues
In This Issue
Erie Reader Best of Erie City Guide 2023-2026

Popular This Week

COVID-19 Cases Rise Slightly In Erie County, Across Country

xRepresentx, Vice, Counterfeit, Cop Torture at BT

Ludacris Shows Behrend Some Southern Hospitality

Best of Erie 2014 Finalists

Hangin' Out at the South Pier

Related Articles

How to Be a Highly Effective Leader: A Primer

by Cassandra Gripp11/16/2026, 11:00 AM
Jefferson Educational Society's Andrew Roth, Ph.D., discusses his new book

Erie Reader Book Club: Strange as This Weather Has Been by Ann Pancake

by Ally Kutz11/11/2026, 10:00 AM
Shop Local choice for November meeting

Ms. Macabre Hosts Alphabetical Horror Show of Nightmarish Creatures

by Erin Phillips10/16/2026, 8:00 AM
Enter the creatively creepy mind of local graphic novelist Adam Calfee

Smith Creative Writers Reading Series: Molly McNett

by Gabby Rodriguez10/12/2026, 1:00 PM
On process, self-doubt, and taking the "long way"

Erie Reader Book Club: October 2026

by Ally Kutz10/12/2026, 10:00 AM
Rosemary's Baby by Ira Levin

Mabeline's Poetry Corner: YOU BELIEVED

by Mabel Howard9/24/2026, 8:00 AM
Member of Reporters Shield
© 2026 Great Lakes Online Media
PO Box 10963  //  Erie, PA 16514
Editorial Standards Terms of Use Privacy Policy