Search ErieReader.com
DonateBest of Erie40 Under 40TicketsAdvertiseDistributionIssuesAboutContactEventsNewsletter
Close
Donate!
Best of Erie 2026
40 Under 40
The Reader Beat
Tickets
Newsletter Signup
Erie Reader Business Quarterly
City Guide
Events
Opinion
Features
Issues Archive
Events Calendar
Advertise
More
Arts & Culture
Business
Columns
Community
Environment
Film
From the Editors
Gem City Style
Local, Original Comics
Music Reviews
News & Politics
Recipes
Sports
Theater
Distribution Locations
About Us
Contact Us
Issue Archives
Internship Opportunities
Write for Us
Share:
MusicMusic Reviews

American Wrestlers // Goodbye Terrible Youth

Goodbye Terrible Youth is a perfect soundtrack for the fall season.

by Nick Warren
View ProfileTwitterInstagramRSS Feed
November 23, 2016 at 12:30 PM

American Wrestlers

Goodbye Terrible Youth

Fat Possum Records

4.25/5 stars

Brilliant and wonderfully chimey, Goodbye Terrible Youth has a comforting sound. There's a 90s throwback that mixes with the twee charm you'd get from high school covers of The Cure. This album follows up the band's spectacular 2015 eponymous debut. The St. Louis quartet picks up the tempo a little bit, with a steady finger-tapping rhythm from start to finish. The record is a perfect soundtrack for the fall season. There's just something about fuzzy lo-fi indie rock that pairs perfectly with autumn leaves and cardigans. The sound is freeing: Gary McClure's voice is high and soft a la Robert Schneider (the Apples in Stereo) or Doug Martsch (Built to Spill). Despite the cheerful sounding exterior, the lyrics make good on the album title's promise. Personal accounts are woven into bleak tales of growing up and coping with our modern age. Chorus-less songs go on, repeating melodies, but not repeating lyrics. The depths are there to visit when you need to, but the words linger, heavily obscured and distorted into a shoegaze lullaby. 

– Nick Warren

american wrestlersgoodbye terrible youthfat possum recordsgary mcclureshoegaze

Featured Events

Today Tomorrow This Weekend

Erie Reader Book Club: Rosemary's Baby

Literary Arts
Oct. 25th, 1 PM

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory

Performing Arts
Oct. 25th, 2 PM

Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas in Concert

Music
Oct. 25th, 3 PM

Lake Erie Launchpad​: Emerging Erie Entrepreneurs

Community & Causes
Oct. 27th, 7 PM to 8:30 PM

King Sickabilly LIVE! At Centennial Hall

Music
Oct. 28th, 6 PM

Submit Your Event   View Calendar

October 2026: Halloween
Erie Reader: Vol. 16, No. 10
View Past Issues
In This Issue
Erie Reader Best of Erie City Guide 2023-2026

Popular This Week

COVID-19 Cases Rise Slightly In Erie County, Across Country

xRepresentx, Vice, Counterfeit, Cop Torture at BT

Ludacris Shows Behrend Some Southern Hospitality

Best of Erie 2014 Finalists

Hangin' Out at the South Pier

Related Articles

Album Review // This Is Lorelei // The Singer in My Band

by Nathaniel Clark10/21/2026, 8:00 AM

Local Album Review // In Addendum // Boom!

by Aaron Mook10/14/2026, 7:00 AM

Local Album Review // Lanternflies // Lanternflies

by Nick Warren10/7/2026, 1:00 PM

Celebrate Cinematic Splendor and The Nightmare Before Christmas

by Erin Phillips10/6/2026, 11:00 AM
The Erie Philharmonic presents both Symphonic and Pops concerts for October

Complete the Cycle: Brother's Keeper Returns to Erie

by Larry Wheaton10/5/2026, 8:30 AM
30 years later, Mike Ski and Chris Bazan reflect on Erie's formative scene

Local Album Review // Maniacal Device // Caveman Thrash Metal

by Larry Wheaton10/1/2026, 1:00 PM
Member of Reporters Shield
© 2026 Great Lakes Online Media
PO Box 10963  //  Erie, PA 16514
Editorial Standards Terms of Use Privacy Policy